DOWN X DOWN › players › compare
Updated Nov 3, 9:16 AM ET
2026

2026 season · compare · backs

Compare players

Two or three players of the same position, side by side: where each one grades against the league, where the ball finds each of them, and how their weeks line up.

70 in the league pool
Who · up to three, same position groupStart over
33
Bhayshul TutenRB · Jaguars · graded
✕
23
Christian McCaffreyRB · 49ers · graded
✕

The address bar is the share link. Copy it, text it, post it: whoever opens it sees the same players. The Compare button on player pages builds on this set until you start over or switch positions.

This week · each one's next game and the defense at his positionHalf PPR
Week 9 · Thursday · Bhayshul at RavensRavens allow the 10th-fewest RB points
Week 9 · Sunday · Christian vs RaidersRaiders allow the 7th-most RB points
Where they rank · among 70 backs with 30 touches+League percentiles
Bhayshul TutenChristian McCaffrey
Yards per carry
4.566th
4.678th
Rush EPA per carry
0.0074th
+0.1496th
EPA per targetreceiving, 5+ targets
+0.8898th
+0.0357th
Broken tacklesper touch
1%51st
2%84th
Explosive rate10+ run, 20+ catch per touch
13%89th
10%64th
Touches per game
18.073rd
18.073rd
Receiving sharetargets per touch
13%29th
33%92nd
Yards per touch
5.386th
5.178th

Each bar is the league pool; the markers are the players. Right is better, the dashed line is the median. The best value in each row is marked green.

Playstyle · how each is used, against the league's backsamong 70 backs
Bhayshul TutenChristian McCaffrey
BhayshulUnder centerMotion man
ChristianPass-catching backMotion manThird-down back
Inside runscarries at guard or tackle
47%36th
46%35th
Shotgun runscarries from the gun
21%14th
23%16th
Receiving sharetargets per touch
13%29th
33%92nd
Third-down shareof team touches on 3rd down
8%42nd
24%89th
Red-zone shareof team touches inside the 20
32%74th
37%82nd
Short-yardage shareof team touches, 2 or fewer to go
27%64th
32%74th
RPOcarries on run-pass options
0%6th
1%15th
Motiontouches with pre-snap motion
71%76th
79%92nd

Every trait is a share of his own touches, so volume does not move it. Each bar is the league's qualifying backs; the markers are the players and the thin line is the median. Styles are not grades: a high or low share describes the role, not how well he plays it. The tags are each player's traits furthest from the middle.

The shape · percentile radarBigger and rounder is more complete
YPCRush EPAEPA / tgtBrk tacklesExplosiveTouchesRec shareYds / touch
Where he wins · EPA per target by lane and depthSame scale across
Bhayshul Tuten
Loading…
Christian McCaffrey
Loading…

Green cells turn targets into points, red cells lose them. Cells with one target are left grey.

Where the EPA comes from · the season split by what happened on his playsRushing and receiving EPA

Christian McCaffrey gets the most on runs (+12.1 EPA), Bhayshul Tuten gets the most after the catch (+29.6 EPA), and Christian also gives the most back on targets he does not catch (−8.4).

Bhayshul Tuten+13.8
Christian McCaffrey+13.5
Air yardsAfter the catchIncompletionsInterceptionsDesigned runs
PartBhayshulChristian
Air yardson catches−15.1−0.94 a target · 5th−9.9−0.24 a target · 95th
After the catch+29.6+1.85 a target · 99th+19.7+0.47 a target · 19th
Incompletionstargets not caught−0.5−0.03 a target · 91st−8.4−0.20 a target · 29th
Interceptionswhen targeted0.00.00 a target · 54th0.00.00 a target · 54th
Designed runs−0.3−0.00 a carry · 74th+12.1+0.14 a carry · 96th
Total+13.8126 touches+13.5126 touches

Every play is split by what happened: completions at the catch into air yards and yards after the catch (nflverse's air EPA), the cost of the ones that fell incomplete or were picked, and his designed runs. Bars share one scale, gains right of the line and losses left. The rate is per carry for runs and per target for catches, with its percentile among the league's qualifying backs; the best rate in each row is green.

Where the ball finds them · same scale, same fieldloading plays

Bhayshul Tuten

Loading…

Christian McCaffrey

Loading…

Designed carries by gap, from each team's play file.

On one field · every target, same fieldFilled is caught, a ring is not
Loading…
Depth butterfly · B.Tuten and C.McCaffreySolid is caught
Loading…

Back to back by depth band. The widest band is where the offense goes to him; the gap between solid and faded is where it misses.

The race · cumulative yardsFlat steps are byes
Week by week · groupedSame Sunday, side by side
The shape of their seasons · each one's last 3 games, week by weekWeeks 1 to 8
Bhayshul TutenChristian McCaffrey

Toucheslast 3 games

719
12345678
Bhayshul 19.7Christian 18

Scrimmage ydslast 3 games

2483
12345678
Bhayshul 114Christian 100

EPA / touchlast 3 games

-0.28+0.11
12345678
Bhayshul +0.18Christian +0.21

Targetslast 3 games

14
12345678
Bhayshul 3Christian 6.7

Each line is a player's trailing 3 games (rates are pooled over the games, not averaged); the faint dots are single games. The shaded band is the league's middle half of single games at the position, the dashed line its median. A line that climbs out of the band is a role getting bigger.

Floor and ceiling · boom, solid or dud, week by weekBoom 83+ · dud under 24
B.Tuten
88Wk 162Wk 290Wk 391Wk 496Wk 587Wk 67Wk 7159Wk 8
96 ± 28
C.McCaffrey
88Wk 166Wk 2116Wk 370Wk 483Wk 5117Wk 6100Wk 78Wk 8
91 ± 19

Thresholds are the quartiles of every game week by qualified backs this season (459 player weeks). The right column is the average week and its swing.

Fantasy · points, rank and range, week by week
StandardB.TutenC.McCaffrey
Points a game14.8RB1015.7RB7
Season103.3RB14110.0RB13
Most weeks9.2–19.613.3–18.4
Booms · busts4 · 012+ · under 56 · 012+ · under 5
Half PPRB.TutenC.McCaffrey
Points a game15.8RB1318.1RB3
Season110.8RB15127.0RB10
Most weeks10.2–21.414.8–20.4
Booms · busts3 · 016+ · under 6.54 · 016+ · under 6.5
PPRB.TutenC.McCaffrey
Points a game16.9RB1320.6RB3
Season118.3RB15144.0RB7
Most weeks11.2–23.216.3–22.5
Booms · busts2 · 020+ · under 84 · 020+ · under 8

Ranks are among players at each one's own position. A missing bar is a week he did not score: a bye or a missed game. The format you pick is remembered on this device.

Week by week · aligned
WeekB.TutenC.McCaffrey
Wk 16668
Wk 26523
Wk 37375
Wk 47352
Wk 57268
Wk 63964
Wk 7·39
Wk 8104·
Season492389

Rows are league weeks, so byes and missed games show as gaps. The best value each week is marked green.

Season stats · side by side, with league rank
SeasonB.TutenC.McCaffrey
Carries11084
Rush yards492389
Rush TD38
Targets1642
Yards per carry4.524th4.616th
Rush EPA per carry0.0019th+0.143rd
EPA per target+0.882nd+0.0328th
Broken tackles1%35th2%12th
Explosive rate13%8th10%26th
Touches per game18.019th18.019th
Receiving share13%50th33%6th
Yards per touch5.310th5.116th
Careers · scrimmage yards a game, season by seasonRegular season
Bhayshul TutenChristian McCaffrey
50100150
20172019202120232026*
PlayerGCarYdsTDYds/gBest seasonThis season
Bhayshul Tuten2025 to 2026 · 2 seasons221931,0591348.12025: 38625.7 a game96.1above his career rate
Christian McCaffrey2017 to 2026 · 10 seasons1191,74213,619106114.42019: 2,392149.5 a game91.4below his career rate

Regular season only, from each player's career file. * 2026 is through Week 8; its dot is hollow because the season is not over. "This season" compares this year's rate with his earlier seasons. Hover a dot for the season's line.