DOWN X DOWN › players › compare
Updated Nov 3, 9:16 AM ET
2026

2026 season · compare · tight ends

Compare players

Two or three players of the same position, side by side: where each one grades against the league, where the ball finds each of them, and how their weeks line up.

45 in the league pool
Who · up to three, same position groupStart over
88
Charlie KolarTE · Chargers · graded
✕
82
Treyton WelchTE · Saints · not yet qualified
✕

The address bar is the share link. Copy it, text it, post it: whoever opens it sees the same players. The Compare button on player pages builds on this set until you start over or switch positions.

This week · each one's next game and the defense at his positionHalf PPR
Week 9 · Sunday · Charlie vs TexansTexans allow the 5th-fewest TE points
Week 9 · Sunday · Treyton vs BrownsBrowns allow the 10th-most TE points
Where they rank · among 45 tight ends with 15 targets+League percentiles
Charlie KolarTreyton Welch
Target shareof team targets
12%37th
--
Depth of targetair yards per target
5.432nd
--
After the catchyards per reception
2.98th
--
Catch ratereceptions per target
59%3rd
--
EPA per target
-0.901st
--
First downsper target
29%23rd
--
Drop ratedrops per target, lower is better
18%1st
--
Yards per game
19.619th
--

Each bar is the league pool; the markers are the players. Right is better, the dashed line is the median. The best value in each row is marked green.

Playstyle · how each is used, against the league's tight endsamong 45 tight ends
Charlie KolarTreyton Welch
CharlieWins before the catchRarely deepNo screens
Treytonnot graded yet
Deep sharetargets 20+ yards downfield
0%9th
0%–
Screensshare of his targets
0%12th
0%–
Middle of the fieldtargets between the numbers
29%77th
0%–
After the catchshare of his yards after the catch
30%8th
––
Third-down shareof team targets on 3rd down
7%30th
0%–
Red-zone shareof team targets inside the 20
9%30th
0%–
Motiontargets with pre-snap motion
59%49th
100%–
Play actiontargets off play action
24%40th
100%–

Every trait is a share of his own targets, so volume does not move it. Each bar is the league's qualifying tight ends; the markers are the players and the thin line is the median. Styles are not grades: a high or low share describes the role, not how well he plays it. The tags are each player's traits furthest from the middle.

The shape · percentile radarBigger and rounder is more complete
Target shareDepthYACCatch rateEPA / tgtFirst downsDropsYds / game

Treyton Welch is not graded yet, so no shape.

Where he wins · EPA per target by lane and depthSame scale across
Charlie Kolar
Loading…
Treyton Welch
Loading…

Green cells turn targets into points, red cells lose them. Cells with one target are left grey.

Where the EPA comes from · the season split by what happened on his playsReceiving EPA

Charlie Kolar gets the most from the ball in the air (+5.0 EPA), Treyton Welch gets the most after the catch (0.0 EPA), and Charlie also gives the most back on targets he does not catch (−3.6).

Charlie Kolar−15.2
Treyton Welch−0.6
Air yardsAfter the catchIncompletionsInterceptions
PartCharlieTreyton
Air yardson catches+5.0+0.29 a target · 79th0.00.00 a target
After the catch−2.8−0.17 a target · 1st0.00.00 a target
Incompletionstargets not caught−3.6−0.21 a target · 50th−0.6−0.58 a target
Interceptionswhen targeted−13.8−0.81 a target · 1st0.00.00 a target
Total−15.217 targets−0.61 target

Every play is split by what happened: completions at the catch into air yards and yards after the catch (nflverse's air EPA), the cost of the ones that fell incomplete or were picked. Bars share one scale, gains right of the line and losses left. The rate is per target, with its percentile among the league's qualifying tight ends; the best rate in each row is green.

Where the ball finds them · same scale, same fieldloading plays

Charlie Kolar

Loading…

Treyton Welch

Loading…

Targets placed by air yards and side of the field, from each team's play file.

On one field · every target, same fieldFilled is caught, a ring is not
Loading…
Depth butterfly · C.Kolar and T.WelchSolid is caught
Loading…

Back to back by depth band. The widest band is where the offense goes to him; the gap between solid and faded is where it misses.

The race · cumulative yardsFlat steps are byes
Week by week · groupedSame Sunday, side by side
The shape of their seasons · each one's last 3 games, week by weekWeeks 1 to 8
Charlie KolarTreyton Welch

Targetslast 3 games

26
12345678
Charlie 4.7Treyton 0.3

Rec yardslast 3 games

1153
12345678
Charlie 25.7Treyton 0

EPA / targetlast 3 games

-0.31+0.66
12345678
Charlie -1.18Treyton -0.58

aDOTlast 3 games

3.48.5
12345678
Charlie 5.7Treyton 17.0

Each line is a player's trailing 3 games (rates are pooled over the games, not averaged); the faint dots are single games. The shaded band is the league's middle half of single games at the position, the dashed line its median. A line that climbs out of the band is a role getting bigger.

Floor and ceiling · boom, solid or dud, week by weekBoom 53+ · dud under 11
C.Kolar
0Wk 121Wk 23Wk 34Wk 437Wk 520Wk 67Wk 720Wk 8
20 ± 12
T.Welch
0Wk 10Wk 23Wk 30Wk 40Wk 50Wk 67Wk 78Wk 8
0 ± 0

Thresholds are the quartiles of every game week by qualified tight ends this season (326 player weeks). The right column is the average week and its swing.

Fantasy · points, rank and range, week by week
StandardC.KolarT.Welch
Points a game1.6TE540.0TE97
Season7.8TE640.0TE109
Most weeks1.4–2.00.0–0.0
Booms · busts0 · 59+ · under 30 · 49+ · under 3
Half PPRC.KolarT.Welch
Points a game2.6TE510.0TE97
Season12.8TE590.0TE109
Most weeks2.0–3.50.0–0.0
Booms · busts0 · 512+ · under 40 · 412+ · under 4
PPRC.KolarT.Welch
Points a game3.6TE490.0TE97
Season17.8TE550.0TE109
Most weeks2.4–5.00.0–0.0
Booms · busts0 · 315+ · under 50 · 415+ · under 5

Ranks are among players at each one's own position. A missing bar is a week he did not score: a bye or a missed game. The format you pick is remembered on this device.

Week by week · aligned
WeekC.KolarT.Welch
Wk 100
Wk 221·
Wk 4·0
Wk 537·
Wk 620·
Wk 820·
Season980

Rows are league weeks, so byes and missed games show as gaps. The best value each week is marked green.

Season stats · side by side, with league rank
SeasonC.KolarT.Welch
Targets171
Receptions100
Yards980
Touchdowns00
Target share12%29th-
Depth of target5.431st-
After the catch2.942nd-
Catch rate59%44th-
EPA per target-0.9045th-
First downs29%35th-
Drop rate18%45th-
Yards per game19.637th-
Careers · receiving yards a game, season by seasonRegular season
Charlie KolarTreyton Welch
2550
20222023202420252026*
PlayerGRecYdsTDYds/gBest seasonThis season
Charlie Kolar2022 to 2026 · 5 seasons3840507413.32025: 14210.9 a game19.6above his career rate
Treyton Welch2026 to 2026 · 1 season20000.02026: 00.0 a game0.0first season

Regular season only, from each player's career file. * 2026 is through Week 8; its dot is hollow because the season is not over. "This season" compares this year's rate with his earlier seasons. Hover a dot for the season's line.